What new keycaps would we like to see?

(Jared Harris) #1

At some point Keyboardio will get to considering more keycaps. I bet it would help them (and us) if they know which ones would be most desired by current owners. I have thoughts which I’ll post but I’m just going on my own experience. It would be helpful to know other perspectives and maybe some consensus will emerge on the most valuable choices.

(Jared Harris) #2

I used a Kinesis for many years, plus of course other “normal” keyboards. I got my Keyboardio a couple of weeks ago and after several days of difficulty I figured out which keys were giving me problems and remapped the keyboard. Now I can type with little or no difficulty. Great keyboard!

I can also switch to “normal” keyboards easily again. As I was adapting to the original layout I was starting to have problems switching.

The moved location of the shift and enter keys was the most painful aspect of the layout. The location of tab was also a significant pain point.

The remapping I adopted puts most keys in places familiar for US typists (similar to most US keyboards including Kinesis) or in a few cases adopts a familiar layout in a new location (e.g. inverted T arrow keys, bracket keys). Since many keycaps no longer reflect the actual function, if I had to look I’d find it very confusing, but I’m a typist who rarely looks at the keyboard. The main problems are when I have to find a little used key.

I have moved my existing thumb keys around to reflect my layout as best I can, but I’m missing extras for duplicated keys and one keycap (enter). Perhaps some of the non-thumb keycaps could be swapped but I have not experimented with this since so many shapes are specific to locations.

So I can get along OK, but ideally I’d like new key caps that reflect this layout. I also think a layout with some of these proposals would make adoption of the keyboard much, much smoother for US users.

Below is a list of my desired new keycaps ordered by my guess at likely ease / popularity of production. Conflicts with the existing layout are noted, in some cases there is no conflict so no note. Conflicts resolved by other moves in the same group are not noted. Apologies for any errors.

Extra copies of existing thumb keycaps (should be easy!):

  • An extra ALT (OPT preferred for us Mac users, but that would be a new key)
  • An extra CMD

New keycaps:

Convenience (high priority case):

  • ENTER as a thumb key

Moving keys back to more typical locations (high priority cases):

  • ESC as PROG
  • SHIFT as PGDN (PGDN can be FN PGDN)
  • SHIFT as “_” (see proposed relocation of underbar to a more typical location)
  • TAB as PGUP (PGUP can be FN PGUP)

Convenience (lower priority cases):

  • CTRL as ESC (see proposed move of ESC to a more typical location)

Making the arrow keys back into an inverted T (adopted by many layouts in the “Share your layout” thread):

  • UP ARROW as FN “I” (see proposed relocation of “}”)
  • DOWN ARROW as FN “K"
  • LEFT ARROW as FN “J”

Many of the layouts also had the inverted T arrow keys on the left hand.

———— END of very generic requests ————

Bracket keys:
There are many possible ways of configuring these. This proposal gets them back on the main layer, back to the typical shifted / unshifted relationship, and out of the way of inverted T arrow keys:

  • “{” (whole key) as “any” (“any” can be FN “any”)
  • “}" (whole key) as “enter” (see proposed thumb key “enter”)

To move keys back to more typical positions (lower priority cases):
Note these are the whole keys not just the quoted character.

  • “_” as “+”
  • “+” as “~”
  • “~” as TAB (see proposed move of TAB)
  • “|” as LED (LED can be FN LED)

(Bart Nagel) #3

I think sets of extra thumb keys is certainly a valuable idea, especially since they are identical in shape.

As for the rest, I think there would be so many different things wanted in so many different places I don’t imagine they’d happen until/unless fully custom engravings are available. There are the blank black, blank white, and undecipherable keycaps to fill in the gaps where there’s no keycap matching your actual usage.

Having said that, I haven’t kept an eye on the “share your layout” topic, so maybe the requests are a lot more focussed than I imagine. I guess we’ll find out in this thread!

(fedward) #4

I’m resigned to never getting a QGMLWY keycap set but I’d love different thumb keys with homing dots. In my personal setup that would mean removing the homing dot on bksp and adding one for cmd but I’m not sure how other people would vote.

(Andrew Wilson) #5

I can’t fathom why we have two control keys and only one Alt. The Alt keys do diffent things in lots of software, the Ctrl keys are pretty interchangable.

I’d like another thumb Alt,
backspace on Num
enter key back where I’m expecting it (below current num)
I have any mapped to Num
Tab on backtick
page up and down on the other hand (same locations)

I’m guessing these are not going to be universal.